瀛﹁€呴【鍐啲 鍙戣〃浜? 2010-6-20 14:07:09
鍒嗙被锛氭潅璁恒€傗攤锛? 鈹? 娴忚锛?21       鎺ㄨ崘缁欐湅鍙?/span>  

濂戒箙娌″湪杩欓噷鍐欑偣涓滆タ浜嗭紝鍩烘湰棰犺浜嗘垜浠ュ線鎿呭啓甯栧瓙鐨勭弽璐典紶缁熴€備粖澶╃獊鐒舵劅鍙楄壇娣憋紝浜庢槸鍐欑偣涓滆タ鍝堛€?/span>

鏈€杩戞悶瀹氫簡涓€绡?/span>J Phys D Appl Phys鍜屼竴绡?/span>Mater Sci Eng A銆傚彧鏄紝鐜板湪鍥藉唴楂樻牎宸茬粡寮€濮嬭捣鐢ㄦ瀬鍏蜂腑鍥界壒鑹层€?/span>ISI鐪嬩簡鍌荤溂鐨勫垎鍖哄埗搴︼紝杩欎袱涓湡鍒婂湪鍥藉唴鏄?/span>3鍖猴紝鍦ㄦ垜浠鏍″睘浜庝竴妫嶅瓙鎵撴鐨勬湡鍒婏紝鎵€浠ヨ鏂囧彂浜嗕篃绛変簬鐧藉彂銆傚彧鏄幇鍦ㄧ殑鐮旂┒鎵€杩樺緢璁ゅ彲杩欎袱涓湡鍒婏紝姣曠珶MSEA鍦ㄦ潗鏂欏姞宸ュ伐绋嬮鍩熺殑璁ょ煡搴﹁繕涓嶉敊銆?/span>

鎴戞槸鏉愭枡鍔犲伐宸ョ▼瀛︾鐨勶紝鐮旂┒宸ヤ綔鍦ㄦ潗鏂欏姞宸ュ拰鏈烘涔嬮棿寰樺緤銆傚湪杩芥眰楂樺奖鍝嶅洜瀛愮殑鏃楀笢涓嬶紝鎴戝績娼編婀冿紝璺冭穬娆茶瘯銆傛€庢牱浣垮緱鏉愭枡鍔犲伐鐨勭爺绌跺唴瀹癸紝鑳藉彂2宸﹀彸鐨勬湡鍒婏紝杩樼湡璐逛簡鑷繁寰堝鑴戠瓔銆傝繕濂斤紝鏃╁湪2007骞达紝灏辫浼嶈开·鑹句鸡鐨?/span>“浼︽暒涓夐儴鏇?/span>”涔嬩竴銆婅禌鏈偣Match Point銆嬫墍鎶樻湇锛屽苟涓旀湁鎵€鎰熸偀锛屽彲鑳戒篃澶氫簭婕備寒涓绘紨鏂槈涓?/span>·绾︾堪閫婄粰浜嗘垜澶鐏垫劅锛?/span>^_^ 浜庢槸涔庯紝鎴戝喅瀹氫笉璧板甯歌矾锛屽鎵撴摝杈圭悆銆佹摝缃戠悆锛岃幏寰楀睘浜庤嚜宸辩殑Match Point銆?/span>

浠ヤ笅鍐呭锛屾棤浠讳綍璋冧緝涔嬫剰锛屾牴鎹湰浜虹粡鍘嗭紝璇磋瀹為檯鎯呭喌銆?/font>

1锛夋姇绋?/span>J Phys D Appl Phys

鎴戝繀椤绘壙璁わ紝杩戜箮鍋氭満姊板姞宸ョ殑鎴戯紝瑕佹兂鎶曠墿鐞嗙被鐨勬湡鍒婏紝浠ュ墠鍋氭ⅵ閮芥病鎯宠繃銆傜洰鍓嶇殑鐮旂┒锛屾垜涔熷湪娴╂旦鑽¤崱鐨勭撼绫虫疆娴佷腑锛岃刀鏃堕浼煎湴鐢ㄤ簡浜涚撼绫虫潗鏂欍€傚仛绮夋湯鏉愭枡鎴愬舰鍔犲伐鐨勪汉锛屾渶閲嶈鐨勶紝灏辨槸鐪嬩腑绮夋湯缁忓姞宸ュ浐鍖栦箣鍚庣殑鑷村瘑搴︺€傚鏋滄部鐫€杩欐潯鑰佽矾锛屾祴娴嬭嚧瀵嗗害銆佹祴娴嬪姏瀛︽€ц兘锛屼篃灏卞彧鑳芥姇鎶曟潗鏂欏伐鑹虹被鐨勬湡鍒婏紝鎴戞兂褰卞搷鍥犲瓙涓嶄細瓒呰繃1銆?/span>

濂藉湪锛屾垜杩樿繘涓€姝ユ繁鍏ヨ瀵熶簡鍔犲伐鏉愭枡鐨勬樉寰粍缁囷紝鐢变簬鎴戝悜鏉ヤ竴绌蜂簩鐧藉仛绉戠爺锛屾垜鏈€鍒濆彧鑳界敤鍏夊鏄惧井闀滅湅鐪嬫樉寰粍缁囷紝浣嗘垜杩樻槸鏁忛攼鐨勫彂鐜帮紝鎴愬舰鏉愭枡涓湁闈炲父缁嗗皬鐨勭粍缁囥€傞毦閬撴槸绾崇背缁撴瀯锛熷綋鏃跺績閲岀湡鏄竴鎯娿€傚洜涓哄湪婵€鍏夊姞宸ョ殑瓒呴珮娓╁害涓嬶紝鍘熷绾崇背绮変綋鑳藉湪楂樻俯涔嬪悗淇濇寔鍘熷厛绾崇背缁撴瀯锛屾槸寰堜笉绠€鍗曠殑銆?/font>

蹇冮噷椤挎椂涓€闃垫縺鍔紝浜庢槸棰勭害鍋氫簡鍦哄彂灏?/span>SEM鏄惧井闀溿€傚彂鐜版垜涔嬪墠鐨勯鏈燂紝鐨勭‘鏄幇瀹炪€傝繖涓椂鍊欙紝涓€涓棶棰樺氨鎽嗗湪浜嗘垜鐪煎墠——涓轰粈涔堢撼绫崇粨鏋勫湪婵€鍏夊姞宸ラ珮娓╀腑娌℃湁闀垮ぇ锛熷埌搴曟槸浠€涔堢墿鐞嗘満鍒跺湪閲屽ご锛?/span>

褰撴椂锛岀湡浣╂湇鑷繁鏁簬鎯冲埌“鐗╃悊”鏈哄埗銆傛垜鏁㈡兂鍒?ldquo;鐗╃悊”浜屽瓧锛屽凡缁忕畻鏄垜鐨勮繘姝ヤ簡銆備簬鏄紝鍦ㄦ縺鍏変綔鐢ㄦ満鍒躲€佹櫠浣撶敓闀挎満鍒剁瓑鏂归潰锛屾煡闃呬簡寰堝鐗╃悊鐨勮祫鏂欙紝瑙ｉ噴鐨勪篃寰堝ソ銆傜寷鐒跺彂鐜帮紝鎴戣鏂囬噷锛岀珶鐒舵湁sufficient physics銆備簬鏄紝鎶曠墿鐞嗙被鐨勬湡鍒婏紝鎴愪簡鑷繁鐨勪竴绉嶉€夋嫨銆傛渶鍚庯紝鎴戞姇绋垮埌浜?/span>J Phys D Appl Phys锛屾垜蹇呴』鎵胯锛岃繖瀵逛簬鎴戣繖涓悶鍔犲伐鐨勪汉鏉ヨ锛岀湡鏄釜鎿﹁竟鐞冦€?/span>Match Point浜嗐€?/span>

璇勫鎰忚璇佹槑锛屾垜杩欎釜鎿﹁竟鐞冩晥鏋滆繕涓嶉敊锛?/span>2涓绋夸汉灞呯劧閮芥病鎻愬暐鎰忚锛?/span>

In this paper, the Selective Laser Melting of a TiCx/Ti powder as a new production route for the production of Ti/TiC nano-composite material was investigated. The present phases are identified and the nanometer and submicron level microstructure of the parts, produced at different scanning speeds, are characterized. A sound qualitative explanation for the formation and the non-formation of the nano-sized phase in relation to the process parameters is given.

This paper is relevant for researchers in the field of Additive Manufacturing, in specific Selective Laser Melting and in the field of the production of nanomaterials. The authors do demonstrate the formation of the nano-sized phase and give a qualitative, but sound explanation about the formation this phase in relation to the specific process conditions.

The paper is novel, clearly written and well organized. Also the given results are convincing and significant.

鎵€浠ワ紝鎴戣寰楋紝鍙鏁㈡兂鏁负鏁㈡寫鎴橈紝鎴戜滑鍙互璺ㄥ绉戣蛋寰楁洿杩溿€?/font>

2锛?/span>Mater Sci Eng A淇敼

Mater Sci Eng A鐜板湪鐨勫绋垮彉寰楅潪甯镐弗鏍硷紝灏ゅ叾鏄編鍥戒富缂栦箣涓€E.J. Lavernia銆備絾杩欎釜鏈熷垔姣曠珶鏄潗鏂欏姞宸ュ伐绋嬮鍩熻鐭ュ害姣旇緝楂樼殑鏈熷垔锛屼簬鏄?/span>2涓湀鍓嶆姇浜嗙瘒璁烘枃鍒?/span>MSEA銆備笂鍛ㄦ敹鍒板绋挎剰瑙侊紝鍏朵腑锛屽绋夸汉鎻愬嚭浜嗕笅闈㈣繖涓棶棰橈紝

The authors presented some discussions on elemental diffusion on the powder particles based on EDS results. However, it is inaccurate to talk about the elemental behavior based on EDS analysis. XPS or other advanced methods are required. Therefore, the discussion given in PP. 10-11 is not relevant.

涔嶇湅锛岄】鏃跺偦鐪硷紝瑕佽ˉ鍋?/span>XPS銆備慨鏀硅鏂囨椂锛岃ˉ鍋氬疄楠岋紝鎬绘槸璁╀汉涓嶇埥鐨勩€傜劧鍚庯紝鑷繁浠旂粏鐞㈢（浜嗗绋夸汉鐨勬剰瑙侊紝鍙戠幇涓昏浣撶幇鍦ㄤ笅鍒?/span>2鏂归潰锛?/span>1锛?/span>EDS涓嶅噯锛岃€屽鏋滃仛XPS鏄噯纭殑锛?/span>2锛屽垵绋夸腑鍩轰簬EDS鐨勮璁猴紝涓嶆伆褰撱€傜敱浜庢€ラ渶杩欑瘒璁烘枃锛屾垜鍦ㄤ慨鏀规椂锛屾病鏈夊仛XPS锛岃€屾槸閫氳繃涓嬮潰杩欎釜“鎿﹁竟鐞?rdquo;瀹屾垚浜嗕慨鏀癸紝鍥炲濡備笅锛?/span>

We totally accept your criticism that the EDS analysis is infeasible for the determination of the elemental content. Thank you very much for your kind reminding of this mistake. In the present revised manuscript, we think that using the XRD, SEM, and TEM characterization methods can well study the morphological changes and microstructural development during powder processing. Therefore, the inaccurate discussion based on the EDS analysis given in Pages 10-11 in our previous manuscript has now been excluded in the present version.

淇敼涓绘棬濡備笅锛?/span>1锛屾壙璁よ嚜宸辩殑閿欒锛岃櫄蹇冩帴鍙楀绋夸汉鎰忚锛?/span>2锛屼慨鏀圭鍒犻櫎涔嬪墠鍩轰簬EDS鐨勮璁洪儴鍒嗭紱3锛屽憡璇夊绋夸汉锛屾湰涓殑鍏朵粬琛ㄥ緛缁撴灉XRD, SEM, and TEM宸茬粡鑳藉灞曠ず鏉愭枡鐨勭粍缁囨紨鍙橈紱4锛岃█涓嬩箣鎰忥紝XPS鎴戞殏鏃跺氨娌″仛锛堝綋鐒跺洖澶嶆剰瑙佷腑锛屽喅涓嶈兘鎻愯繖鐐癸紝璁╁绋夸汉璇勫垽鍘诲惂锛夈€?/span>

杩樺ソ锛屼慨鏀圭椤哄埄閫氳繃璇勫锛岀粨鏋滃綍鐢ㄣ€傚綋鐒讹紝鍒╃敤杩欎釜“鎿﹁竟鐞?rdquo;瀹屾垚浜嗕慨鏀癸紝蹇冮噷姣曠珶杩樻槸涓嶇埥銆傝繘涓€姝ョ殑XPS鍒嗘瀽锛岃繕鏄娣卞叆杩涜銆?/span>

鍦ㄦ姇绋垮拰淇敼鐨勬椂鍊欙紝濡備綍鎵撹繖鏍风殑鎿﹁竟鐞冦€佹摝缃戠悆锛屽叾瀹炶繕鏄渶瑕佹垜浠湪骞虫棩澶氬姞绉疮銆傛垜鐨勫仛娉曞拰閫夋嫨锛屾湭蹇呮纭紝浣嗗彲鑳藉湪鏌愪簺鏉′欢涓嬶紝鏈夊叾鍙鎬с€傛垜鍙槸鎸夌収鐜板疄鎯呭喌锛屾祦姘磋处浼肩殑鍐欏嚭鏉ワ紝姝ｇ‘涓庡惁锛屽悇浜鸿嚜鏈変綋浼氥€?/font>

鏈€鍚庯紝绁濈寰峰浗闃熻兘鍦ㄤ笘鐣屾澂璧板緱鏇磋繙锛?/font>